FPR Dry-Run — Dalata Hotel Group (DHG.IR / DAL.L)

Tier-4 Demo · No plugins · WebSearch only · Hindsight back-test

TickerDHG.IR / DAL.L

Sector Adapterhotels_hospitality

Data Tier4 (WebSearch only)

CurrencyEUR (reporting + analysis)

Methodology HashFPR_v1.0-a3f2 [demo]

Run Date16 Apr 2026

Historical Financials — 6 Years Sub-Agent #1 · Data Ingest

€m	FY19	FY20	FY21	FY22	FY23	FY24	H1'25	Confidence
Revenue	≈429 DERIVED	136.8	253.0	366.0	607.8 DERIVED	652.2	306.5	0.85
Operating Profit	null	null	33.0	77.0	null	null	null	0.55
Adj EBITDA	null	null	null	null	223.2 DERIVED	234.5	102.5	0.80
Adj EBITDA after Lease	null	null	null	null	null	173.2	null	0.90
Pre-tax Profit / (Loss)	null	(111.5)	null	null	null	null	null	0.85
Post-tax Profit / (Loss)	78.2	(100.7)	null	null	null	null	null	0.85
Free Cash Flow (post-capex)	null	null	null	null	null	123.7	null	0.85
Net Debt / EBITDA after Rent (x)	null	null	null	null	null	1.3	null	0.90
Cash + Undrawn Facilities	null	null	null	null	null	364.6	null	0.90
Dividends Paid	null	null	null	null	null	27.1	null	0.90
Buybacks	null	null	null	null	null	48.7	null	0.90
Stock-based Compensation	null	null	null	null	null	null CAPABILITY_LIMIT	null	0.00

Coverage: ~30% of full 6-year matrix (vs 16.3% on MSFT last run — better because Dalata IR publishes Irish + LSE filings in English). Flags raised: 2 DERIVED (FY19 revenue from -68%, FY23 revenue from +7.3% growth prior-year), 1 SBC field blocked (requires 10-K equivalent deep-read — needs Tier 2/3 data).

Returns on Capital vs Pineal Thresholds Sub-Agent #3 · Returns + DuPont

ROIC (TTM Jun'24)

3.89%

FAIL vs Pineal >10% threshold

ROCE (TTM Jun'24)

6.3%

BELOW hospitality avg 7.8%

Return on Equity

4.43%

FAIL vs cost of equity

Revenue CAGR '19→'24

8.75%

PASS vs Pineal >5% (COVID-noisy)

DuPont decomposition: full ladder (margin × turnover × leverage) blocked at Tier 4 — needs segment P&L and average invested capital per year. Flagged DUPONT_DECOMPOSITION_GAP. Regime tag: FY20 = COVID bucket; FY22–H1'25 = recovery/rate-hiking bucket — ROIC trend must be read within regime, not across.

Hotels_Hospitality Sector Adapter KPIs Sub-Agent #4 · Sector Adapter

KPI	FY19	FY20	FY24	H1'25	Direction
Group Occupancy	82.6%	30.9%	null	null	RECOVERED, not fully disclosed at group level for '24
Dublin Occupancy	null	null	83.5%	null	Above pre-COVID baseline
Regional Ireland Occupancy	null	null	77.2%	null	-290bps YoY
Dublin ARR (€)	null	null	158.08	null	-0.8% YoY
Group RevPAR (€)	null	27.45	null	109.78	LFL -2% H1'25
EBITDA margin (Adj)	null	null	35.96%	33.4%	-250bps H1'25 vs FY24 run-rate
EBITDAR margin (after lease)	null	null	26.56%	null	Strong vs UK-Ireland hotel peers
WALT / Debt Maturity Ladder	null	null	null	null	CAPABILITY_LIMIT — Tier 2/3 required

Adapter fit: full match — hotels_hospitality.md KPI set (RevPAR / ADR / Occupancy / EBITDAR / rent coverage / same-store growth) populated at ~60% coverage from WebSearch. Rent coverage ratio derivable from EBITDA vs EBITDAR (€234.5m → €173.2m → lease cost ≈ €61.3m → rent coverage ≈ 3.8x STRONG).

Financial Quality Score + Red Flags Sub-Agent #6 · Scoring + Report

Band C · Mediocre

Category	Weight	Score	Driver
Growth Quality	15	9	Strong '22–'24 rebound but cyclical, COVID-distorted base
Profitability	20	13	EBITDA margin healthy, op margin middling for hotels
Cash Flow	20	11	FCF €123.7m solid; conversion sensitive to growth capex cadence
Returns on Capital	20	5	ROIC 3.89% well below WACC — core drag on score
Balance Sheet	15	12	1.3x leverage, €365m liquidity headroom, BS is the strength
Earnings Quality	10	5	Partial — SBC data blocked at Tier 4, [ASSUMPTION]

RED FLAGS TRIGGERED

RED ROIC below WACC for 3+ consecutive years (3.89% vs ~8% hotels WACC)
AMBER RevPAR declining LFL in H1'25 despite Dublin outperformance
AMBER Revenue growth (+1% H1'25) substantially slower than prior 3y trajectory
DATA SBC magnitude unverified — cannot confirm Rule #1 dilutive SBC flag

NO FLAGS (PASSED)

OK Cash conversion OCF/EBITDA-after-rent ≈ 71% (above 70% threshold)
OK Leverage stable at 1.3x — no spike YoY
OK Buybacks (€48.7m) + divs (€27.1m) = €75.8m — fully FCF-funded, not debt
OK Rent coverage ≈ 3.8x (strong for hospitality)

Variant View + Hindsight Validation Sub-Agent #5 · Forecast + Variant

Lens	View	Evidence
Consensus (pre-review, Mar'25)	Low-growth, capital-intensive hotel operator. Share price +6% over 4 years.	ROCE 6.3% < industry avg; RevPAR softening; unexciting trading narrative.
FPR Variant View	Low opco ROIC masks embedded real-estate value. At 1.3x leverage with €365m liquidity, the balance sheet carries takeover optionality that consensus is not pricing.	Owned-freehold portfolio + sale-and-leaseback architecture means PropCo/OpCo split is achievable. Cash flow covers shareholder returns without balance-sheet stress.
Falsifiable Thesis	Within 24 months, either (a) a strategic review is announced, OR (b) NAV/share converges toward market price through asset disposals.	If neither occurs and ROIC stays <5%, the bear case (dead money) wins.

HINDSIGHT VALIDATION (16 Apr 2026): Strategic review launched 19 Mar 2025 → Pandox/Eiendomsspar initial €1.3bn bid rejected Jun'25 as undervaluing → final €1.4bn cash offer @ €6.45/share agreed 15 Jul 2025 → completed 7 Nov 2025 at €1.7bn EV. Deal structure = explicit PropCo (Pandox + Eiendomsspar) / OpCo (Scandic manages, option to buy opco for €500m by late 2026). Premium: 35.5% to pre-review price, 49.7% to 12-month VWAP. The "embedded real estate value" thesis was exactly what the consortium monetised. FPR v1.1 would have flagged this setup as a C-grade operator with deep-value asymmetry ahead of the catalyst.

Post-Output Wrap Mandatory · Rule #8

What Changed

Dalata delisted 7 Nov 2025 — no longer in Pineal investable universe
Sector adapter hotels_hospitality exercised for first time
Coverage 30% vs 16.3% MSFT — Irish/UK filings more webcrawlable than US
Hindsight validation available — rare & instructive

Open Items

SBC, working capital, capex by year — all blocked at Tier 4
Full DuPont ladder — needs segment P&L
Debt maturity / WALT — needs 10-K equivalent deep-read
Reference portfolio for score calibration still to build

What Scales

Hotel peer set (Whitbread, PPHE, IHG, Accor, Dalata-at-takeout) benchmark
The "low ROIC / high NAV" pattern — generalisable to REITs + asset-heavy
Irish mid-cap back-test pool for score calibration (C-grade cohort)
PropCo/OpCo split signal = catalyst flag for other hospitality names

Risks

Tier-4 coverage ceiling is hard — next test needs Koyfin+FMP subscription
Hindsight bias: score calibrated against known outcomes = overfit
Sector adapter needs EU-specific KPIs (bedroom tax, site fees) for UK hotels
Rule #5 (falsifiable thesis) still being tested — this is the first live case

Source Log (Excerpt) Rule #3 · Audit Trail

Field	Value	Source	Confidence	Timestamp
Revenue FY24	€652.2m	Dalata FY24 Results PDF	0.95	2026-04-16
Adj EBITDA FY24	€234.5m	Dalata FY24 Results PDF	0.95	2026-04-16
FCF FY24	€123.7m	Alpha Spread / Dalata IR	0.85	2026-04-16
ROCE TTM Jun'24	6.3%	Simply Wall St	0.75	2026-04-16
ROIC	3.89%	Simply Wall St / derived	0.70	2026-04-16
FY20 Revenue	€136.8m	Irish Times / Hospitality Ireland	0.85	2026-04-16
FY20 Pretax Loss	€(111.5)m	Irish Times	0.85	2026-04-16
Takeover Price	€6.45/share	RTE / Pandox PR	0.95	2026-04-16
Takeover Completion	7 Nov 2025	HotelsMag / Pandox PR	0.95	2026-04-16
SBC FY24	null	CAPABILITY_LIMIT — Tier 4	0.00	2026-04-16

Full source log would be ~60 rows for a complete FPR run. This excerpt demonstrates the audit-trail discipline.

Pineal Capital — FPR Module Build Dashboard